AI search & GEO / ALYGN MARKETING
How do I choose a GEO agency without buying hype?
Ask practical questions about access, content, reporting, and ownership before paying for AI search visibility services.
THE SHORT ANSWER
Choose a provider that explains the work, separates evidence from promises, and connects its reporting to your business goals. Ask for specific deliverables, access requirements, review responsibilities, and measurement limits. Be cautious when a proposal guarantees AI recommendations, sells secret markup, or treats a few selected prompt results as proof.
Ask for a diagnosis before a package
Give the provider one important service page and ask what they would investigate first. A useful answer should distinguish access, factual clarity, customer usefulness, and measurement. It should also state what cannot yet be concluded. For example, an agency that notices contradictory service areas has identified a concrete issue; one that immediately prescribes dozens of AI articles has not necessarily diagnosed anything. Ask which changes are essential, which are experimental, and what evidence would cause the provider to change its recommendation. Keep these answers with the proposal.
Inspect claims and reporting methods
Google says normal SEO applies to its AI features and no special markup is required. OpenAI says allowing search crawling does not guarantee inclusion. Ask the provider how its claims fit those limits. If it reports visibility from prompts, request the exact questions, dates, settings, and full answers, including misses. If it reports citations, ask whether those are separated from recommendations and leads. A persuasive presentation is not a substitute for a reproducible method or an honest explanation of what the data does and does not show.
Make ownership and stopping rules explicit
The agreement should state who owns the content, who approves factual changes, what account access is needed, and how work is documented. Set a first review around completed improvements and meaningful outcomes rather than a guaranteed mention count. Decide how to pause experiments that produce little useful evidence. A small business might start with an access review and two priority pages before approving a larger programme. That staged decision protects the budget and gives both sides a concrete basis for judging whether further work is justified.
YOUR NEXT MOVE
Start with this.
- Request a page-specific diagnosis and itemized scope.
- Challenge guarantees and inspect reporting methods.
- Agree ownership, approval rules, and a review point.
A credible provider makes the work understandable and the uncertainty explicit before asking for a larger commitment.
Go straight to the source.
Want this off your plate?
SEO at Alygn